| 1855 John C. Rafferty |
1900 Benjamin F. Honness |
1945 George Butler |
| 1856 Marston D. Treffern |
1901 Benjamin F. Honness |
1946 E. Clifford Coss |
| 1857 Marston D. Treffern |
1902 John W. Sharp |
1947 William V. Sherman |
| 1858 Augustus E. Sanderson |
1903 John W. Sharp |
1948 Harold A. Vannatta |
| 1859 Augustus E. Sanderson |
1904 John W. Fulper |
1949 Karl A. Wagner |
| 1860 Elijah R. Hall |
1905 John W. Fulper |
1950 George R. Thompson |
| 1861 Elijah R. Hall |
1906 John W. Sharp |
1951 Walter S. Reid |
| 1862 John R. Emery |
1907 John W. Sharp |
1952 H. Lawall Harvey |
| 1863 John R. Emery |
1908 Morris W. Robinson |
1953 Lester W. Humphrey |
| 1864 John R. Emery |
1909 John Tine |
1954 Charles W. Lowe |
| 1865 John R. Emery |
1910 John W. Sharp |
1955 John W. Abel |
| 1866 Augustus E. Sanderson |
1911 James Nelson Alpaugh |
1956 Leroy D. Eyler, Jr. |
| 1867 Augustus E. Sanderson |
1912 Frank A. Esty |
1957 Howard Frace, Jr. |
| 1868 Richard H. Gano |
1913 Frank A. Esty |
1958 Ernest Bright, Jr. |
| 1869 Richard H. Gano |
1914 John H. C. Rowland |
1959 Harry P. Britton |
| 1870 William E. Hoffman |
1915 George B. Rittenhouse |
1960 Charles W. Hildebrant |
| 1871 Jacob A. Kline |
1916 Melvin H. Roberson |
1961 Joseph S. Bird |
| 1872 Richard H. Gano |
1917 Marion M. Bonnell |
1962 Frederick A. Braun |
| 1873 Herman Altemus |
1918 Charles G. Wyckoff |
1963 Floyd W. Morrow |
| 1874 Herman Altemus |
1919 Austin H. Coleman |
1964 Gerhard H. Schwedes |
| 1875 Herman Altemus |
1920 Walter D. Wright |
1965 John W. Hetherington |
| 1876 William D. L. Robbins |
1921 Charles V. Hoffman |
1966 Bill Prostak |
| 1877 William D. L. Robbins |
1922 Joseph H. Williams |
1967 Ben Galio |
| 1878 William D. L. Robbins |
1923 Clarence F. Alpaugh |
1968 Charles E. Housel |
| 1879 William H. Baker |
1924 A. W. Booraem |
1969 J. Lionel Cohen |
| 1880 William H. Baker |
1925 J. Ramsey Hoffman |
1970 Harry P. Apgar |
| 1881 William H. Baker |
1926 J. Philip Exton |
1971 Edward A. Marut |
| 1882 William H. Baker |
1927 Joseph H. Williams |
1972 Barry S. Campbell |
| 1883 Herman Altemus |
1928 Foster V. Hulsizer |
1973 Edward P. Morrish |
| 1884 Henry V. Bodine |
1929 Alvah H. Haver |
1974 Richard P. Jones |
| 1885 Henry V. Bodine |
1930 Van R. S. Lowe |
1975 George E. Kirchin |
| 1886 William Knight |
1931 Joseph W. Hawk |
1976 William A. Reed |
| 1887 Frank Rundio |
1932 Leroy MacPherson |
1977 John F. Szczepanski |
| 1888 Frank Rundio |
1933 George Herder |
1978 John F. Szczepanski |
| 1889 William H. Gerhart |
1934 Charles L. Hall |
1979 John F. Szczepanski |
| 1890 William H. Gerhart |
1935 Clarence B. Hall |
1980 Charles T. Housel |
| 1891 Henry Latimer |
1936 Harold M. Rowland |
1981 Charles T. Housel |
| 1892 Henry Latimer |
1937 Howard E. Drinkwater |
1982 John H. Meissner |
| 1893 A. Lincoln Smith |
1938 Adolph Miller |
1983 Joseph F. Tapp |
| 1894 A. Lincoln Smith |
1939 A. R. Archer |
1984 Paul E. Reed |
| 1895 Frank Latimer |
1940 Rinehart L. Berger |
1985 Paul E. Reed |
| 1896 Frank Latimer |
1941 Clarence E. Selover |
1986 John H. Meissner |
| 1897 Henry E. Aller |
1942 John A. Schweitzer |
1987 Granville V. Robinson |
| 1898 Henry E. Aller |
1943 A. E. Campion |
1988 Charles T. Housel |
| 1899 Herman Altemos |
1944 Herman Schlobohm |
1989 Charles T. Housel |