| 1826 Imla Drake |
1881 Isaac J. Eyears |
1936 Alvah H. Lance |
| 1827 Imla Drake |
1882 Isaac J. Eyears |
1937 Joseph H. Gardner |
| 1828 ~ Unknown ~ |
1883 Isaac J. Eyears |
1938 Charles B. Hixson |
| 1829 Benjamin Egbert |
1884 Isaac J. Eyears |
1939 Charles B. Hixson |
| 1830 Benjamin Egbert |
1885 William H. Parker |
1940 Willard F. Wiesel |
| 1830 Benjamin Egbert |
1886 John C. Reeves |
1941 Leslie W. Green |
| 1832 Abner Parke |
1887 John C. Reeves |
1942 William B. Terriberry |
| 1833 Imla Drake |
1888 Isaac J. Eyears |
1943 George T. Conkling, Jr. |
| 1834 Abner Parke |
1889 Isaac J. Eyears |
1944 Charles A. Ely |
| 1835 Abner Parke |
1890 Isaac J. Eyears |
1945 George T. Conkling, Jr. |
| 1836 Abner Parke |
1891 John M. Shannon |
1946 Wesley M. Winter |
| 1837 Abner Parke |
1892 Theodore Castner |
1947 Ferdinand H. Young |
| 1838 Abner Parke |
1893 Isaac J. Eyears |
1948 Charles B. Hixson |
| 1839 Abner Parke |
1894 Isaac J. Eyears |
1949 Charles B. Hixson |
| 1840 Abner Parke |
1895 Isaac J. Eyears |
1950 Theodore B. Hunt |
| 1841 Richard Rounsawell |
1896 James M. Tomey |
1951 Edward P. Ames |
| 1842 William H. Parke |
1897 William Frank Fritts |
1952 Walter N. Ames |
| 1843 ~ Lodge In Darkness ~ |
1898 William Frank Fritts |
1953 Jacques Staples |
| 1844 ~ Lodge In Darkness ~ |
1899 James R. Umberger |
1954 Walter N. Ames |
| 1845 ~ Lodge In Darkness ~ |
1900 Edgar E. Riddle |
1955 Walter N. Ames |
| 1846 ~ Lodge In Darkness ~ |
1901 Edgar E. Riddle |
1956 Warren G. Fleming |
| 1847 ~ Lodge In Darkness ~ |
1902 Isaac J. Eyears |
1957 Warren G. Fleming |
| 1848 ~ Lodge In Darkness ~ |
1903 ~ Unknown ~ |
1958 Joseph V. Martin, Jr. |
| 1849 ~ Lodge In Darkness ~ |
1904 ~ Unknown ~ |
1959 Joseph V. Martin, Jr. |
| 1850 ~ Lodge In Darkness ~ |
1905 Isaac J. Eyears |
1960 Charles D. Strunk |
| 1851 ~ Lodge In Darkness ~ |
1906 John H. Nunn |
1961 Charles D. Strunk |
| 1852 ~ Lodge In Darkness ~ |
1907 John H. Nunn |
1962 Charles D. Strunk |
| 1853 ~ Lodge In Darkness ~ |
1908 Harry A. Hunt |
1963 Robert C. Smith |
| 1854 ~ Lodge In Darkness ~ |
1909 Charles E. Wallender |
1964 Robert C. Smith |
| 1855 ~ Lodge In Darkness ~ |
1910 Theodore B. Fulper |
1965 Joseph V. Martin, Jr. |
| 1856 ~ Lodge In Darkness ~ |
1911 John H. Nunn |
1966 Charles Zimmerman |
| 1857 ~ Lodge In Darkness ~ |
1912 Joseph F. Flynn |
1967 George W. Hackett |
| 1858 ~ Lodge In Darkness ~ |
1913 Joseph F. Flynn |
1968 Elwood G. Stump |
| 1859 ~ Lodge In Darkness ~ |
1914 George O. Gardner |
1969 Joseph J. Kinney |
| 1860 ~ Lodge In Darkness ~ |
1915 Joseph D. Sigfried |
1970 Wayne Crisp |
| 1861 ~ Lodge In Darkness ~ |
1916 Paul C. Carling |
1971 George W. Hackett |
| 1862 ~ Lodge In Darkness ~ |
1917 John D. Stofels |
1972 Eugene Fleming |
| 1863 ~ Lodge In Darkness ~ |
1918 Watson Rinehart |
1973 Charles D. Strunk |
| 1864 ~ Lodge In Darkness ~ |
1919 Edgar N. Lance |
1974 Elwood G. Stump |
| 1865 ~ Lodge In Darkness ~ |
1920 H.K. Hansen |
1975 Charles D. Strunk |
| 1866 ~ Lodge In Darkness ~ |
1921 H. Kiefer Lance |
1976 Dewey Buchanan |
| 1867 ~ Lodge In Darkness ~ |
1922 Charles B. Hixson |
1977 Dewey Buchanan |
| 1868 ~ Lodge In Darkness ~ |
1923 Howard J. Dalrymple |
1978 Robert H. Peschel |
| 1869 ~ Lodge In Darkness ~ |
1924 Clayton E. Green |
1979 Robert S. Carpenter |
| 1870 David Bruce |
1925 Edsen A. Potter |
1980 Arthur W. Weightman |
| 1871 David Bruce |
1926 Frank C. Newman |
1981 Robert R. Vickery |
| 1872 Robert Fozard |
1927 Joseph H. Gardner |
1982 Addison H. “Bud” Fishburn |
| 1873 Monroe Curtis |
1928 Russell W. Gordon |
1983 John D. Polt |
| 1874 John C. Tomey |
1929 Eyears Worman |
1984 Bruce E. Stymacks, Sr. |
| 1875 John C. Tomey |
1930 Eyears Worman |
1985 Robert J. Rauf |
| 1876 James Huntsman |
1931 Robert L. Wurst |
1986 Curtis W. Murphy |
| 1877 John C. Reeves |
1932 Robert L. Bogart |
1987 Curtis W. Murphy |
| 1878 Peter S. Shurts |
1933 Wilbur K. Lance |
1988 George A. Koschker |
| 1879 Harrison S. Peterbough |
1934 Alvah H. Lance |
1989 Kenneth A. Moore |
| 1880 John M. Shannon |
1935 Eyears Worman |